Bring RCMP into Caledonia, poll says

Ontarians also want Ottawa to take over negotiations in native land dispute

ANTHONY REINHART
Global & Mail
Oct 20, 2006

Most Ontarians want the federal government to take over negotiations in the native land dispute at Caledonia, and the RCMP to provide policing of the eight-month-old protest, according to a poll commissioned by the union that represents increasingly frustrated Ontario Provincial Police officers.

The poll, obtained by The Globe and Mail in advance of its release today, says eight out of 10 Ontarians think Ottawa should take charge of talks with Six Nations protesters, and that two-thirds want the RCMP to join the OPP in keeping peace at the site, southwest of Hamilton.

A majority of respondents, 58 per cent, also wanted a deadline on negotiations, after which the protesters should be removed.

The results are welcome news to OPP officers charged with policing what their union leader calls an "impossible" situation that has led to several confrontations -- some of them violent -- since the protest began on Feb. 28 on a subdivision site under construction.

Print Edition - Section Front

A judge ordered the native protesters off the land in March, and on April 20, the OPP moved in to clear the site. But, hours later, hundreds more demonstrators returned and set up barricades, forcing police to retreat and tempers to rise among non-aboriginals in Caledonia.

Officers then faced several rallies by town residents, including one on May 22 in which some exchanged punches and slurs with the demonstrators. Further clashes followed in June and August, and fears of more violence arose last weekend when a Richmond Hill man led a counterprotest rally, which ultimately passed without incident.

In the meantime, the province bought the disputed land from the developers in June, and has been meeting with Six Nations and federal officials to discuss the natives' claim that the land was taken from them illegally by the Crown.

But as long as the protesters remain, the OPP face the possibility of further flare-ups, along with the wrath of town residents who see them as ineffectual.

"We agree with Ontarians; it's time for both the federal government and the federal police force to assume their responsibilities in Caledonia," Karl Walsh, president of the 7,500-member OPP Association, said in a written statement.

"We commissioned this poll because our members are being asked to do the impossible, and they've been doing it since this standoff began in late February. They cannot and should not be negotiating and policing at the same time."

Progressive Conservative Leader John Tory, who has visited the town several times, said he listened as residents heaped scorn on OPP officers for inaction, not realizing individual officers have no authority to end the protest.

"They're despondent, I think, about the fact that they believe it has really tarnished their reputation as a group of people that are sworn to and are diligent in seeing that peace, order and good government are maintained," Mr. Tory said.

He has called for an inquiry "at the appropriate time" to establish that front-line officers did not decide on their own on how to handle the protest, and to identify who, within the government and the OPP, made those decisions.

In the meantime, Mr. Tory said the solution is to bring an end to the protest while continuing to deal with the land claim.

"The best tonic for the morale of the citizenry of Caledonia, the citizenry of the first nations community and the police would be to take more aggressive steps to bring this to an end," he said.

The telephone survey of 601 Ontario residents, done by Pollara Inc., was conducted between Sept. 27 and Oct. 1, and has a margin of error of plus or minus 4 per cent, 19 times out of 20.

The poll's release comes amid high-level changes at the OPP. On Oct. 30, Julian Fantino, the former Toronto police chief, will take over as OPP commissioner. Also, OPP Deputy Commissioner Jay Hope, who had been overseeing Caledonia, will leave the force to succeed Mr. Fantino as Ontario's commissioner of emergency management, effective Nov. 14, Premier Dalton McGuinty announced yesterday.

When Mr. Fantino's appointment was announced last week, Mr. Walsh lauded it as a positive step toward improved police leadership at Caledonia.

But Mr. Fantino has offered few hints of how he will approach the high-priority case.

He will not comment further on Caledonia until he takes up his new post, Bruce O'Neill, a spokesman for Emergency Management Ontario, said yesterday.

Ontarians on Caledonia

Results of an Ontario Provincial Police Association poll:

Do you think the federal government should be the one negotiating with the First Nations?

Agree: 80%

Disagree: 13%

Don't know: 7%

Do you think the RCMP should be asked to take part in policing Caledonia?

Yes: 67%

No: 23%

Don't know: 10%

SOURCE: POLLARA