Link to Original Story

Tasered teen's father questions death

Winnipeg man thinks 17-year-old son may have been drunk or stoned, but asks why police did not try other means to disarm him

JOE FRIESEN

From Friday's Globe and Mail

July 25, 2008 at 3:16 AM EDT

WINNIPEG — The father of a 17-year-old who died after being tasered says police told him his son's heart stopped after he was hit in the chest with an electronic probe.

Brian Minchin said his son, Michael Langan, was as healthy as a horse, and used to walk four or five miles a day in pursuit of aluminum cans, trying to scrounge together enough money for some beer and marijuana.

He said his son may have been drunk or high on marijuana when he was confronted by two police officers in an alley close to the National Microbiology Laboratory in Winnipeg's downtown core. Police say they ordered Mr. Langan to drop a knife, and when he refused they were forced to taser him.

He was pronounced dead on arrival at a Winnipeg hospital on Tuesday. He is the 22nd person since 2003 to die in Canada after being tasered by police.

Recent

"He was asked to drop the knife or something and he didn't do it. I guess they asked him several times. Maybe he was drunk. He probably was drunk because he gets kind of crazy and brave when he's drunk," he said. "People think they're Superman when they're drunk, even adults."

Mr. Minchin wants to know why police didn't try to use means other than a taser to disarm his son.

"They're trained to disarm people. He doesn't have a gun. He's not 6 foot 5. He's a 5-foot-4 kid," he said. "They didn't have to tase him. Now I have no son. Seventeen years old!"

Mr. Minchin, who is Métis, said his son had a problem with authority figures of all types, and may have hesitated when told to drop a weapon. But he wonders why police could not have waited a little longer before shocking him with 50,000 volts.

"They said they tasered him once in the chest," he said. "Obviously the taser is the reason he had this heart attack or whatever. He had no heart problems. He was a perfectly healthy 17-year-old kid."

Mr. Langan had been living with his father in a Point Douglas rooming house for the past few weeks, ever since he and his mother returned to Winnipeg from British Columbia. They had gone west in search of a new start, but returned when things didn't turn out as planned. They were still in the process of finding a home in Winnipeg.

In the meantime, Mr. Langan spent a lot of time with his father, who panhandles in an area off Main Street near an old Canadian Pacific Railway station.

His father says somewhat sheepishly that their relationship wasn't perfect. They sometimes smoked marijuana together, and he recognizes his own substance-abuse problems. Hope for his son's future was all he had, Mr. Minchin said.

He said he doesn't have many memories of his son, but will always cherish the thought of the day they spent together when the Grey Cup was last in Winnipeg. Mr. Minchin scalped half a dozen tickets and then went into the stadium to watch the game with his son. They smoked joints and drank beers at halftime, he said.

When the police told him his son had died, he was heartbroken.

"I just started crying, 'No, no, he can't be dead.' "

An official cause of death has yet to be released by the provincial medical examiner. Reports from the scene suggested Mr. Langan was bleeding from the head, but Mr. Minchin believes it was his heart that failed.

It's strange, he said, because his son always used to say he would die young.

The incident began when two citizens saw someone police say was Mr. Langan breaking into a car outside a garment factory a few blocks from the spot where he died. The two men followed him for several minutes and flagged down a passing police car. The officers took over the chase and confronted Mr. Langan in a back alley adjacent to the grounds of the laboratory.

Minutes later, witnesses said, they were pounding on his chest trying to revive him with the help of paramedics.

Two officers have been placed on administrative leave while the incident is investigated by the Winnipeg police homicide unit. Once that investigation is complete, it will be sent to an outside police agency for review.

David Chartrand, president of the Manitoba Métis Federation, said yesterday that there are questions about whether racial profiling was a factor in the case. But at a news conference yesterday, Winnipeg Police Chief Keith McCaskill played down the racial angle, saying everyone must wait for the full investigation to unfold.

"Certainly if you look at the specifics that we can provide you, we had two citizens approach the police, direct them to a certain person and that's where [officers] went," Chief McCaskill said.

Mr. Minchin said he plans to sue the police.